Amy's Custom Cakery, Logo

(717) 292-0880
83 W Canal Street, Dover, PA 17315

About Us

Amy's Custom Cakery opened on December 5, 2011, but owner-operator Amy Wasser has been decorating cakes since she was 16. Since opening the shop, she and our staff have created thousands of specialty cakes along with hundreds of wedding cakes and countless other desserts, such as cupcakes and our famous cake balls.

For custom orders, we use buttercream and rolled fondant to distinguish our specialty wedding cakes. If you want a quick treat for lunch or to take home, choose something from our display case that is full of cupcakes, brownies, cookies, chipwiches, snoballs, and cake balls.

(*All cakes are ordered ahead of time by phone! We do not sell cakes out of our display case.)


Shana C. — 5 star This was the first time that I ordered a cake from Amy and it not only was absolutely adorable (a minion) but it was delicious and we had so many compliments on this cake. I will definitely be ordering cakes from you in the future and with 3 kids that will be often. Thanks so much!!

Nicole G. — 5 star Amy's Custom Cakery made the cake and cupcakes for my wedding in June and they were so delicious! I especially loved the raspberry filled cupcakes and red velvet! And the designs for them were exactly how I wanted them. I was very satisfied and would recommend this place to anyone!

Lauren & Jason S. — 5 star My husband got me chocolate covered strawberries for Valentine's Day from here and they were awesome!! We have also used her for my daughter's birthday cake and it was delicious. Very pleased with Amy's Custom Cakery all around!

Michele A — 5 star Greatest cakes ever!! Amy is able to capture any life moment in any flavor and decor!!!

Amy L O. A.— 5 star I had my daughter's baby shower cake made by Amy's, it was moist and so good! I will recommend her to my friends and family!

Brenda B. K. — 5 star I had my daughter's baby shower cake made by Amy's. It not only looked great, it also tasted great as well!! I will be ordering all of my cakes there!

MaryAnn B. — 5 star Her cakes and other sweets are SO good! Try them, you'll love them! She's very talented! Way to go Amy!!

Contact our cake bakery in Dover, Pennsylvania, for services that make your cake beautiful and delicious.